Homemade Mascara Recipe That Works! - Simple Life Mom (2024)

I never wear a lot of makeup, but I like my eye liner, mascara, and lip stick. So, what do you do if you go all natural? You can forget it all and go with your beautiful, clean face (I really wish you would see quite how beautiful that really is!). But if you’re not comfortable with that yet, then how about getting started making your own with this homemade mascara recipe?

I started making my own makeup years ago: foundation, bronzer, eye liner, lip color, eye shadow, blush. I even made my own homemade mascara recipe using egg yolks. I have two recipes you can check out and compare to this one.

Why another homemade mascara recipe?

I like the other recipes, but (1) egg yolk does great for mascara, but I like to make more at once and not have to worry about it going bad quickly. (2) The other recipe I try to use tends to run on warm days.

So, I’ve been playing and tweaking. I made a batch and it was great at first, but got too thick after a day. I made another batch, but it didn’t sit on the lashes as much as I liked. Finally, the recipe below is my final recipe. You may still need to tweak things a little if it’s too thick, too runny, depending on how well you measure your ingredients, but I’ll give you tips on how to do that too.

You really can have a natural, homemade mascara that works well and it pure and healthy for you! Wonderful! Out of all my products, this is the only one I kept going back and forth on with store bought and homemade. I’m finally happy and I hope you will be too.

See Also

French Bread Recipe | The Prairie HomesteadGluten-Free Vegan Apple Spice Cake RecipeOne-Pan Christmas Casserole Recipe (Plus Great Gift Idea with PrintablHow To Make Beard Balm Recipe With Beeswax. DIY In 5 Simple Steps

Homemade Mascara Recipe

Ingredients – affiliate links to help you find ingredients

• Bentonite clay – gives this a great texture and gives lashes more volume. Mountain Rose Herbs has very fine and beautiful Bentonite Clay HERE.
• Glycerin – you can find some good vegetable glycerin HERE.
• Coconut Oil – I like to use fractionated coconut oil in this recipe, otherwise it can become to thick in cold weather.
• Beeswax – beeswax helps to thicken this recipe and helps to hold the mascara onto your lashes. You can find some high quality beeswax HERE
• Shea Butter – Shea butter is best when it is raw and unrefined and it makes for a super silky smooth texture.
• Activated Charcoal – you want to make sure your buy a very fine powder to make a smooth finish to your mascara. HERE is one I’ve used a really liked.
• Essential Oils – I like to add a few drops of rosemary essential oil because it is very good at keeping oils from oxidizing. It is also very good for hair follicles, making it a great ingredient for mascara.

Options and Tips:

1. For a brown tint, add less charcoal and more cocoa powder.
2. Use a syringe or cut a tiny corner off of the bottom of a zip top bag to help squeeze the mascara into the tubes.
3. The place that I used to buy tubes from is gone, but you can find some like these on Amazon.
4. If it is too thick, add a drop of oil and mix. Too thin? Add a pinch of clay and mix. You may have to make another adjustment after a day or so as the clay tends to absorb moisture.

So there you have it! Let us know in the comments below how it turned out for you, what you did differently, etc.